Welcome to The Why Coffee Shop
The Why Coffee Shop serves classic comfort food with a nostalgic twist. Located at 1317 Main St, Niagara Falls, NY, this cash-only diner specializes in breakfast and lunch. Expect an inviting atmosphere filled with local patrons and friendly servers. With a menu that ranges from fluffy pancakes to hearty burgers, this spot caters to everyone from solo diners to families. Its 1970s decor adds to the charm, making every meal feel like a trip back in time. Whether you’re fueling up for a day of exploration or just stopping by for that perfect cup of coffee, The Why Coffee Shop delivers an experience that's both satisfying and memorable.
Popular dishes
Restaurant Gallery
About
The Why Coffee Shop sits in the heart of Niagara Falls at 1317 Main Street, a spot that celebrates the city's local culture. This old-school diner exudes warmth and character, reminiscent of classic roadside eateries. Here, it’s not just the food; it’s the sense of community that draws both tourists and locals alike. Many patrons know each other by name. The intimate setting creates a familial vibe where everyone feels welcome. With a small selection of booths and a curvy counter, patrons can interact over their plates or simply relish a quiet moment with coffee brewed from locally sourced beans.
The atmosphere is laid-back and cosy, ideal for starting your day on the right foot or enjoying brunch with friends. It’s a testament to the diner culture, where meals are prepared with love on the open griddle, and laughter fills the air. Accessibility is a priority with all entries and seating options catered for wheelchair users. A visit here feels like a step into a cherished local tradition, making it clear why this little gem has remained a favorite for years. both locals and tourists flock to The Why Coffee Shop for its history and charm. Don't miss it while in Niagara Falls!
Working Hours
- SundayOpen
- MondayOpen
- TuesdayOpen
- WednesdayOpen
- ThursdayOpen
- FridayOpen
- SaturdayOpen
What People Say
Most Liked
One of the most liked aspects of The Why Coffee Shop is its friendly service. The staff welcomes everyone with a smile, making diners feel at home right away. The casual atmosphere catches the eye, particularly the charming 1970s decor that adds a touch of nostalgia.
The food shines here, especially the breakfast items such as fluffy pancakes, crisp home fries, and perfectly cooked eggs. Diners rave about the generous portions at incredibly low prices, often cited as a major draw. Many appreciate the coffee, praised for its robust flavor and quality. The efficiency of the service during peak hours also makes it appealing, ensuring that patrons get their meals without a long wait.
Most Disliked
The biggest complaint tends to be the cash-only policy. Many find it inconvenient in today's digital world, especially tourists who may not carry cash. It’s a good idea to prepare by bringing some bills before visiting.
Some patrons mention the limited space as a drawback, particularly on busy days. The diner can fill up quickly, leading to wait times during peak hours. While many embrace the cozy environment, others feel it could become cramped. Lastly, the absence of credit card payment options may catch some seats empty, which could set back their experience.
Reviews
Paige M.
This is the perfect breakfast diner! Delicious, greasy food made in an open griddle in front of you, good coffee, friendly servers, very fun curvy dining counter. Prices are very reasonable, all the food in my picture came to about $11-12. I love love love this place.
Cat H.
Found this mom and pop diner on our weekend trip to Niagara Falls, the hometown atmosphere was nothing you see anymore! It's definitely a locals spot, as they knew most of the patrons that were dining. It's a small space, with a few booths/tables and some counter seats; but the place was full when we arrived on a weekday. The service and kindness we received from all of the staff was unmatched to a local chain; they were attentive and kind. The food was great, we ordered everything from a breakfast sandwich to pancakes and bacon; everything was hot and delicious. The menu prices were incredible! I would recommend this little gem to anyone who likes a great diner. Glad we found this little hidden gem! They are cash only! Just a heads up before going in!
Yohei K.
Although this café is located a bit away from Niagara Falls, once you visit, you’ll understand why it has such high ratings! The meal was delicious yet affordable, and the roasted coffee was outstanding. It seems to be a place with history—I even ran into a lovely local lady who has been coming here for 25 years. The staff were all friendly, and they warmly welcomed tourists as well. Definitely worth a visit!
J P.
This place is a hidden gem with two touches of nostalgia! Our French toast and eggs were perfection. The vibrant 1970’s decor was just like the menu prices, so low they seemed unchanged since their opening day decades ago. If you want an authentic Niagara Falls staple, Pass all the places closest to the cookie cutter tourist junk and GO HERE❤️
alex b.
Some of the best breakfast ive ever had at an incredibly affordable price
Doris B.
BEST breakfast EVER!! The French toast is prefect!! And sooo much food!! We’re in town for a day and wanted a good quick breakfast, found it!! Cool older building with a classic diner set up. Great little place!
Virginia L.
Great food, unbeatable price! Went on a Saturday at peak hours and everyone was friendly, slight wait but they were packed. Awesome spot with cool vibes